Navigating the world of wine subscriptions can be daunting. Two clubs that a lot of people come to our site via Google to learn about are the WSJ Wine Club and Naked Wines. Both offer unique approaches to delivering wine to your doorstep, but which one is best for you? We've reviewed both several times over the years. But today we are going even beyond that and checking out what the rest of the Internet in addition to our own reviews! (Do you trust Reddit?)
Overview of WSJ Wine Club and Naked Wines
WSJ Wine Club is affiliated with the Wall Street Journal and offers curated selections of wines, often through introductory offers like 15 bottles for $90. Their model emphasizes value and variety, aiming to introduce members to a broad spectrum of wines. All shipments come in full cases (12-15 bottles) and the wines are generally “white label,” meaning you won't find them anywhere else to purchase and will not necessarily know where the wineries are.
Naked Wines, on the other hand, operates on a crowdfunding model. Members, known as “Angels,” contribute monthly funds that support independent winemakers. In return, they receive access to exclusive wines at discounted prices. You can basically select whatever kind of wines that you want in each shipment, and the minimum is 6 bottles. You can learn about every wine AND the winemaker on their website. Read our full Naked Wines Review with Video!
| The Shipping | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| Specification | ||||
|
||||
Wine Selection and Quality
WSJ Wine Club sources wines from various regions, focusing on providing a diverse mix. However, some users have noted that the selections are often from lesser-known wineries, leading to mixed reviews on quality. The only flexibility that you have in choosing the wines is “red,” “white,” or “mixed.”
“I have found that WSJ wines are mediocre and are sourced from obscure wineries. The wines are generally drinkable but are nothing special.”
— Reddit user wbilly27
Naked Wines prides itself on supporting independent winemakers, resulting in a range of unique offerings. You can choose from many different varietals on their website across a wide spectrum from bubbly to sweet white to dry red. While this approach brings variety, it also means that the quality can vary.
“Not sure I’ve ever seen a Naked Wines wine without a vintage designation. Some Naked Wines have case quantities published which rival many of the ‘prestigious’ releases of the area..”
— Reddit user Artfan1024
Pricing and Value
WSJ Wine Club often attracts customers with introductory deals. The wines come out to around $5 a bottle in the introductory shipment. However, some users have expressed concerns about the value proposition beyond the initial offer as the price goes up significantly.
“I tried the introductory offer and I didn't like any of the wines, was very disappointed. I wouldn't recommend it, even with a coupon or heavily discounted first order.”
— Reddit user Fun_Organization3373
Naked Wines operates on a model where members deposit funds monthly, which can then be used to purchase wines. This system offers flexibility and the potential for savings, especially for regular wine drinkers. The introductory offer is around $6 a bottle. The wines retail for between $18 and 30.
“Overall we find it good value and convenient. They don't send random boxes of wine. We pay $50 per month that is banked to our next order, which we choose ourselves.”
— Reddit user Designer_Praline
Customer Experience and Support
WSJ Wine Club has faced criticism regarding customer service and delivery issues. Their website if very basic–essentially one page allowing you to choose your color of wine and that is it.
“Horrible customer service. Choose another wine club.”
— Reddit user Upper_Sky9712
Naked Wines generally receives positive feedback for its customer support, with users appreciating the company's responsiveness and refund policies. In addition, they have a decent app that allows you to learn more about each wine.
“Had some duds and have always received a refund when we logged our feedback. Had some awesome wines as well.”
— Reddit user Designer_Praline
| The Shipping | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| Specification | ||||
|
||||
Final Verdict: WSJ Wine Club or Naked Wines?
Choosing between WSJ Wine Club and Naked Wines depends on your priorities:
- If you're seeking an introductory offer with a variety of wines and are open to exploring lesser-known labels, WSJ Wine Club might be worth a try. However, be prepared for potential variability in wine quality and customer service experiences.
- If supporting independent winemakers and having control over your wine selections appeals to you, Naked Wines offers a unique model that many find rewarding. The flexibility in choosing wines and the company's customer-centric approach are notable advantages.
Ultimately, both clubs have their merits and drawbacks. Consider your wine preferences, budget, and the importance of customer service in your decision-making process. In addition, be sure to check the Shipping States for each club.
